Teaching the Writer vs Teaching the Composition

I have always felt very strongly about teaching students skills that they will actually use in the real world and helping them to develop into a wonderfully well-rounded person. Now that I'm a mom of a two year old, my feelings about that have intensified.

In teaching young students, my number one goal is creating a literate, thinking person; one who can read and write for a variety of purposes, including enjoyment. Somehow, in our endeavors to reach certain state and national standards we have lost sight of that.

Although we have testing standards we have to reach, that must remain the secondary goal for us as we plan instruction. We must first foster a love for reading and writing and develop deep comprehension and thinking in each. After that is established, we can show our students to how the concepts and strategies we have taught them will translate into a test. We can teach them the "test genre", but only after we have established a solid foundation of skills that they will actually use in real life.

Here's an example:

Students in 4th and 7th grades must write two 26 line essays for the STAAR test: one personal narrative and one expository. Let's think about instruction for that a moment. We have 2 general options:

Teach students how to write 26 line essays. All year. Very specific formula.
Teach the students the craft of writing. Help them discover themselves as writers and expose them to strategies and techniques that real authors use. Then, weeks before the test, help them channel what they know about writing into a brief, concise 26 line essay.

When I think about what I want for my daughter Layla, I want her to dabble in writing all genres (poetry, drama, fiction, personal narrative, persuasive, etc.) and I want her to be able to write for all sorts of purposes (for entertainment, to persuade, to inform), not just for a test. I would be heartbroken if she spent a year learning how to write a 26 line essay. Unfortunately, this is happening in far too many classrooms, schools, and districts.

Let's wake up people. Let's really think about what we are doing and why. There IS a balance that can be achieved! We just have to really think critically ourselves and work together to make it happen.

Comments

Monitoring without Coaching is a Culture Killer

Picture this... 10:07 am - John Monitor notices smoke in the forest behind his house. 10:10 am - John walks into the forest and sees fire, about 5 feet long and 3 feet wide. He snaps a picture on his phone and goes back inside. 10:20 am - John goes back into the forest and sees the fire, which has gotten a little bit larger and snaps another picture of it. He even tells the fire, "You are getting bigger. You shouldn't do that." Then he goes back inside. 10:45 am - John goes back to the fire and sees that it's about 15 feet by 5 feet. In awe, he uses his phone to take a video and tells the fire once again how big it is and that it really needs to snuff itself out. 11:00 am - The fire is in John's backyard. John records the fire, providing of a narrative of what is happening and why it should stop spreading. Now Consider This ... This scenario reminds me of what happens when campus and district leaders spend so much time monitoring that very lit...

3 Important Aspects of Independent Reading

In Elementary classes this year, we have made Read to Self (Independent Reading) a priority. We know from decades of research that one of the simplest and most effective way to increase reading skills is to increase the amount of time students spend reading. We have no control of how much our students read at home, but we are able to give them opportunities to read at school. In grades Kindergarten through 5th grade, students are building stamina in independent reading. By the time students are in the middle of third grade, we hope to have them really engaged in independent reading for 20 minutes per day. I hope that in Middle School and High School we can find creative ways to carve out independent reading time as well. Time Matters Check this graphic out to see the correlation between the minutes a student reads and his/her achievement on standardized tests: ...

Advocating for AISD Active Learning Cycle

Advocating for the Active Learning Cycle by Jessica Estillette Recently, I've embarked on one of the most surprisingly stressful, important tasks I have encountered in my entire life... choosing a school for my daughter. My sweet, sassy, super-smart girl will be entering the amazing world of Kindergarten this Fall and I am really fretting over where to send her! Having been in the field education for 19 years, I have seen the good, the bad, and the ugly when it comes to what happens in classrooms and I am determined to find, or create, an environment in which Layla will thrive. Although the bottom line for most schools is meeting the mark for a basic standard of achievement on set standards, I want so much more Layla. First, I want her to have fun and to be inspired in a loving, nurturing environment. Second, since she is a bright kid and I have no doubt she'll pick up content pretty easily, I am much more concerned about building her s...

Reflections by Estillette

Search This Blog